Niantic’s introduction of Max Battles in Pokémon GO is bringing both excitement and controversy. While these Dynamax and Gigantamax battles promise thrilling encounters, the addition of the new Max Mushrooms item has drawn criticism from players accusing Niantic of further monetizing core gameplay elements.
What Are Max Battles?
Max Battles are Pokémon GO’s take on Dynamax and Gigantamax encounters from Pokémon Sword and Shield. These challenges feature powerful Dynamax and Gigantamax Pokémon, requiring teams of players to work together in person. The harder six-star Max Battles, which house Gigantamax Pokémon, are particularly tough and necessitate strong coordination.
Max Mushrooms: A Boost for Battles
The newly introduced Max Mushrooms are directly borrowed from Pokémon Sword and Shield’s Isle of Armor DLC. In Pokémon GO, they:
- Boost Fast Attacks, Charged Attacks, and Max Moves for Dynamax and Gigantamax Pokémon.
- Double damage output for a limited time.
- Allow stacking for extended timer duration, though the damage boost remains the same.
While these buffs make tough Max Battles more manageable, acquiring Max Mushrooms highlights Pokémon GO’s increasingly pay-to-win mechanics.
How to Obtain Max Mushrooms
Max Mushrooms debuted during the Gigantamax Lapras Max Battle Day on December 8. Currently, the only ways to get them include:
- Event Tickets: A $5 ticket grants access to Timed Research rewards, including one Max Mushroom.
- In-Game Shop: Players can purchase Max Mushrooms directly for 400–1,000 PokéCoins, equating to $4.99–$9.99 for one or three mushrooms, respectively.
Community Backlash
The Pokémon GO community has criticized Niantic for monetizing Max Battles with items like Max Mushrooms, particularly for their high price and limited accessibility:
- Reddit User Entire_Pineapple4732: “A lousy money grab item… priced at $4 a piece and doesn’t even compare to having ONE extra person to battle with you.”
- Joe Merrick (Serebii Webmaster): “Oh cool, they’ve monetised the difficulty. Neat.”
The core frustration lies in the inaccessibility of Max Battles for players in less active areas, compounded by the high cost of Max Mushrooms, which are seen as a band-aid rather than a meaningful solution.
Barriers to Entry
Gigantamax Max Battles are significantly harder than Elite Raids, often requiring 20 players at one location due to the restriction against Remote Raid Passes. This has led many players in smaller communities to feel excluded, further fueling the pay-to-win argument.
Potential Future Updates
Fans have called for Niantic to give Max Mushrooms their original dual functionality from Sword and Shield, including the ability to make Max Soup, which unlocks a Pokémon’s Gigantamax form. For now, the implementation of Max Mushrooms leaves much to be desired, and players are skeptical about Niantic’s monetization direction.
Conclusion
While Max Battles introduce new layers of strategy and excitement to Pokémon GO, their paywall-driven design alienates many players. Niantic’s reliance on monetized items like Max Mushrooms might boost short-term profits, but it risks long-term player dissatisfaction, especially if accessible alternatives aren’t introduced soon.
Pokémon Go Tour: Unova – Dates, Spawns, Bonuses, and Everything You Need to Know